Problem
Many modules are marked as "⚠️ STUB" in README but this isn't reflected in the module POMs or build.
Affected Modules
According to README.md, these are stubs:
jplatform-cluster-etcd
jplatform-cluster-redis
jplatform-cluster-zookeeper
jplatform-registry-etcd
jplatform-registry-eureka
jplatform-storage-s3
jplatform-storage-database
jplatform-storage-redis
jplatform-config-consul
jplatform-config-etcd
jplatform-config-vault
jplatform-rest-api-netty
Impact
- Severity: LOW-MEDIUM
- Category: Documentation/User Experience
- Users may try to use non-functional modules
- Wastes development time debugging "broken" features
- Unclear project roadmap
Required Actions
1. Document in Module POM
Add to each stub module's pom.xml:
<description>
[STUB] Future implementation for XYZ integration.
This module is a placeholder and NOT YET IMPLEMENTED.
See GitHub issues for roadmap.
</description>
2. Add Marker Class
package org.flossware.jplatform.cluster.etcd;
/**
* STUB MODULE - NOT YET IMPLEMENTED
*
* This module is a placeholder for future etcd cluster integration.
* See issue #XXX for implementation tracking.
*/
@Deprecated(since = "1.1", forRemoval = false)
public class EtcdStateStore implements ClusterStateStore {
public EtcdStateStore() {
throw new UnsupportedOperationException(
"etcd integration is not yet implemented. See GitHub issues."
);
}
}
3. Maven Profile to Exclude Stubs
<profile>
<id>exclude-stubs</id>
<activation><activeByDefault>true</activeByDefault></activation>
<modules>
<!-- Only include implemented modules -->
</modules>
</profile>
4. README Badge
Add status badge next to each module:
- jplatform-cluster-etcd 
- jplatform-cluster-consul 
Alternative: Remove Stub Modules
If no implementation planned soon:
- Remove stub modules from main branch
- Create issues for future implementation
- Only add modules when actually implementing
Pros: Cleaner codebase, less confusion
Cons: Loses "roadmap in code" visibility
Priority
P2 - Medium - Should be clarified before v1.2 release.
Related
- README.md (lists stubs)
- ENHANCEMENTS_STATUS.md (may have more details)
Problem
Many modules are marked as "⚠️ STUB" in README but this isn't reflected in the module POMs or build.
Affected Modules
According to README.md, these are stubs:
jplatform-cluster-etcdjplatform-cluster-redisjplatform-cluster-zookeeperjplatform-registry-etcdjplatform-registry-eurekajplatform-storage-s3jplatform-storage-databasejplatform-storage-redisjplatform-config-consuljplatform-config-etcdjplatform-config-vaultjplatform-rest-api-nettyImpact
Required Actions
1. Document in Module POM
Add to each stub module's pom.xml:
2. Add Marker Class
3. Maven Profile to Exclude Stubs
4. README Badge
Add status badge next to each module:
Alternative: Remove Stub Modules
If no implementation planned soon:
Pros: Cleaner codebase, less confusion
Cons: Loses "roadmap in code" visibility
Priority
P2 - Medium - Should be clarified before v1.2 release.
Related